The Better Half by Newton Webb
A Contemporary Psychological Horror Short Story: When Gayle, a disillusioned housewife's slovenly husband transforms overnight into a domestic god, her initial relief rapidly turns to dread.
Contents
Horror Story Compilations
The Better Half
By Newton Webb
Gayle Ingold is at the end of her tether. Her husband of twelve years, Barny, is a classic slob. A man who leaves wet towels on the bed, toenail clippings in the shower, and is utterly blind to household mess.
Gayle’s frustration has reached a boiling point.
One Monday night, her life changed. She finds Barny obsessively cleaning the kitchen at 11 p.m., scrubbing pans with uncharacteristic fervour and offering unsolicited advice on cookware.
Something isn’t right in the Ingold household.
The Better Half
By Newton Webb
Monday, 2 February 2026. Keyworth.
Barny’s lips pursed as he scoured the egg off the stainless steel pan. His shoulders rose and fell. He’d been cleaning the kitchen for two hours. First the skirting boards in the hallway, then the inside of the microwave, the cooker top, and now the washing.
Gayle watched nervously from the doorway with a glass of rosé. Normally, when she was stressed, she would clean. But Barny’s newfound enthusiasm was robbing her of even that relief.
This was not the Barny she’d married twelve years ago. Barny wasn’t a selfish man. Had he been, she’d never have married him. It was just that mess was invisible to him. He would happily leave wet towels on the bed and toenail clippings in the shower. He was a man who would step over a basket of laundry to get to the fridge for a Diet Coke.
“Erm, B? Everything okay?”
Barny flinched. His elbow knocked a bottle of olive oil, which wobbled before settling. He smiled at her, then a look of panic crossed his face as his eyes darted from her face to the floor to the clock on the wall.
“Sorry, love.” He dropped the pan back into the soapy water. “Didn’t hear you. I just got back from my walk and wanted to get this grime off. It builds up, doesn’t it?”
“Are you feeling okay?” She walked over to check his mug. It was empty. “Did you drink all your tea?”
“Yes, it was delicious, thank you.” Barny flexed. “Bit of heart burn while walking, but no dramas.”
“And you are sure that you are alright?” She felt his forehead. It was normal. “Right. Well, it’s eleven o’clock at night.” Gayle’s voice was wary. “You’ve work tomorrow.”
“Is it? God. Time flies.” He wiped his hands on a tea towel. “Good point. I’ll have a shower and join you. Quick note though.”
Gayle clenched the stem of her rosé glass. “Yes, dear?”
“Nonstick for eggs, stainless steel for bacon.” He kissed her cheek as he walked past her.
This is impossible.
“I know, I know. The nonstick was in the dishwasher.”
Barny called over his shoulder. “Nonstick isn’t dishwasher safe.”
Gayle downed her rosé, placing it next to the sparkling hob and the clean mug. She watched her husband disappear up the stairs with a sick feeling in her stomach.
Tuesday, 3 February 2026. Keyworth.
The next morning, Gayle dropped Leo and Sarah at the school gates. They hopped out of the car with their packed lunches. Barny had made ham and cheese sandwiches, cut them into stars, and included little handwritten notes.
Sarah showed her note to Gayle with delight. It read, ‘The universe is a sparkly blur of fast moving shapes jazzed up by deafening noises.’
Gayle bit her bottom lip. “That’s lovely.”
Is he on drugs?
After the school run, Gayle parked the Volvo in the multi storey and walked to her favourite coffee shop, Deja Brew, near the library. Tom was already there, wearing an ethically sourced jumper, sitting at a corner table, and knitting a protest scarf that looked like a rainbow had been violently sick.
“Darling!” Tom didn’t look up from his needles. “What happened? You look.” He looked up from his knitting to regard her through narrow, slitted eyes. “Irked.”
“Remember when I said I was fed up with B?” Gayle sat down and leaned in. “Well, since things came to a head last week after our little spat.”
“The one where you texted me saying, and I quote here, ‘I’m going to murder the lazy son of a bitch.’” Tom stopped knitting. He pushed his glasses up his nose. “What’s he done now? He isn’t voting Reform, is he?”
“Worse. He’s being considerate, Tom.”
“The horror.” Tom returned, unperturbed, to his knitting. One side of his attempt at a scarf was missing a few stitches, and now the whole thing was leaning to one side.
“I’m serious. He is attentive. He does chores. He puts down his books to play with the children.”
Tom picked up his herbal tea. He blew on the surface. “Okay. That is weird, but isn’t this what you wanted?” Tom mused as he sipped his tea. “Maybe he’s had a breakdown, panicking about the thought of being alone? You’ve been unhappy for a long time, love. But maybe, just maybe, he’s actually trying.”
“Mum thinks he’s having an affair.”
“Babs thinks everyone is having an affair because she watches Spanish soap operas.” Tom leaned in. “Look, just give it time. If he starts chanting in Latin or eating raw liver, call me. I have sage. We can smudge the house.”
Thursday, 5 February 2026. Keyworth.
Gayle was in the garden, hard pruning her dormant roses when the phone rang in her pocket. It was the museum where Barny worked.
“Mrs Ingold?”
“Yes, speaking.”
“Hi, sorry to bother you. It’s Derek. I was just wondering if Barny is okay? We haven’t seen him since Tuesday. He hasn’t called in and we have the rest of the Egyptian artefacts to catalogue before the exhibit.”
Gayle froze. She gripped the secateurs tightly. “He hasn’t been in?”
“No. We thought maybe he was sick and just forgot to ring. Is everything alright?”
“Yes,” Gayle forced her voice to be calm. “He’s had a bit of a stomach bug. He’s been sleeping it off. I’ll make sure he calls you tomorrow.”
“Oh, good. Thanks, Mrs Ingold. I hope he feels better. I’ll take over temporarily, but just while he is off. I know how territorial he gets.”
“Wonderful. I’m sure he’ll be grateful.”
Gayle hung up.
She looked at the house.
He left the house every morning at seven thirty in his suit. He returned at six in the evening.
She opened Google Maps on her phone. She tapped on Barny’s icon.
He was not at the industrial estate where his office was located.
The little blue dot sat stationary in the middle of Charnwood Forest, by the river.
Gayle felt a cold prickle at the base of her spine.
Barny didn’t do exercise. He said he walked, but all he did was shuffle around the estate listening to his audiobooks.
What is he doing in the woods?
She was sitting at the kitchen table when he came home.
The key turned in the lock. The door opened. Barny walked in looking tired. His tie was crooked.
“Evening, love.” He beamed at her. “Traffic was murder on the ring road.”
Gayle didn’t move. Her hands were clasped in front of her on the pine table. Next to her hand lay a heavy chef’s knife.
“Sit down, Barny.”
He paused, mid-step. A flash of confusion crossed his face. “Is something wrong?”
“Sit down.”
He sat, placing his briefcase on the floor.
“Your office called.”
“Oh.”
“They haven’t seen you in two days.” Gayle picked up her phone and slid it across the table. The screen showed the tracking data. “And you weren’t at the industrial estate. You were standing still in the middle of Charnwood Forest.”
Barny opened his mouth to speak, a stammered excuse forming on his lips.
“Don’t.” Gayle picked up the knife and admired the edge. “You aren’t Barny.”
There was a long silence.
Then Barny’s eyes hardened. “I’m keeping this body. I need it.”
“Why were you in the forest?”
“Grounding. It takes energy to knit a dead soul to a living world. The forest helped the bond solidify.” The creature narrowed its eyes at the knife. “That blade won’t work on me, Gayle. I’m already dead. Technically.”
“I know.”
The creature tilted its head. “You... know?”
“I know you’re dead.” Gayle stood up. She walked around the table, the knife dangling loosely in her grip. “Because Barny didn’t just have an accident on Monday night, did he?”
“He did. His heart stopped.” The creature watched her warily. “I was watching, I’ve been watching since he released me from my prison. I felt a sudden fire in his stomach, a burning failure of the system. He vacated the premises, so I moved in.”
Gayle poured a glass of rosé with a steady hand. “I’ve been married to Barny for twelve years.” Gayle’s voice dropped to a murmur. “He was lazy, selfish and I was tired.”
She leaned down, her lips brushing the tip of his ear.
“It wasn’t heartburn you felt when you took over, darling. It was the monkshood I put in his Earl Grey.”
The creature turned its head slowly to look at her. The alien detachment in its eyes was replaced by a very human flicker of shock.
Gayle smiled, and for the first time in years, it reached her eyes.
“You’re wonderful with the kids,” she stroked his lapel. “You listen to me. You clean. To be frank... if he had been more like you, I wouldn’t have had to kill him.”
She placed the knife gently back on the table.
“So,” she patted his cheek. “What would you like for dinner? I was thinking we could order in for once?”
FREE Horror Story Compilations
Shadows of Spring: 64 FREE horror stories, including: ‘The Enigmatic Skeleton’, ‘The Doll House Killer’, ‘The Spinster’, ‘The Leprechaun’ and ‘Mind Games’.
The Dark Fiction Spring Sale: 50 horror stories, including ‘Tales of the Macabre, Vol. 1’, ‘Tales of the Macabre, Vol. 2’, ‘Tales of the Macabre, Vol. 3,’ ‘Tales of the Macabre, Vol. 4.’ and ‘Tales of the Macabre: Books 1-4’.
Tales of the Macabre
You can find my stories on Amazon, as Kindle Unlimited, eBook, Paperback or Hardback.
This collection of stories is designed for quick reads, whether over a coffee or during a commute. Either way, they promise to deliver exquisitely disturbing nightmares that gaze without flinching into the abyss—and linger in the mind long after.
FREE on Kindle Unlimited
Available to order on AMAZON.
Welcome to the complete collected works of Newton Webb. Tales of the Macabre, Vol. 1-4 are intended for mature audiences.
Read a collection of free short stories or listen to free audiobooks by Newton Webb on his website.
What a wonderfully terrifying tale, Newton! The end twist took me totally by surprise, though I should have seen it coming :D